patient is consulting a therapist and explaining with injured leg

Key Takeaways

  • Total knee replacement resurfaces the entire knee joint, while partial (unicompartmental) knee replacement resurfaces only the damaged section.
  • Partial knee replacement typically means a smaller incision, less blood loss, and a quicker recovery, but it's only an option when arthritis is limited to one area of the knee.
  • Total knee replacement is usually recommended when arthritis affects multiple parts of the knee or when a patient isn't a candidate for the partial procedure.
  • An orthopedic surgeon determines which approach fits a patient's specific condition through a physical exam and imaging.
  • Cedar Valley Orthopedics performs both total and partial knee replacement in Cedar Falls, IA, using advanced surgical navigation, and patients can request a consultation to discuss which option may be right for them.

Consultations

What Total Knee Replacement Involves?

A total knee replacement is the most common type of knee replacement surgery. It's typically recommended for patients whose arthritis affects multiple compartments of the knee. During the procedure, the surgeon resurfaces the end of the thigh bone (femur) and the top of the shin bone (tibia), replacing the damaged surfaces with metal and plastic components that replicate the knee's natural movement. In some cases, the underside of the kneecap is resurfaced as well.

According to the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, total knee replacement is considered one of the most successful procedures in all of medicine, and it's generally recommended once nonsurgical treatments like medication and walking supports are no longer providing enough relief.

What Partial (Unicompartmental) Knee Replacement Involves?

A partial knee replacement, also called a unicompartmental knee replacement, is an option when arthritis is confined to just one section, or compartment, of the knee — most often the inner (medial) side. Rather than resurfacing the entire joint, the surgeon replaces only the damaged compartment, leaving the healthy bone, cartilage, and ligaments in place.

The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons notes that because partial knee replacement is performed through a smaller incision, patients typically spend little or no time in the hospital and return to normal activities sooner than those who undergo total knee replacement. Many patients also report that a partial knee replacement feels more natural, since more of the knee's original structure is preserved.

Total vs. Partial Knee Replacement: How Recovery Differs

Recovery timelines, candidacy, and long-term outcomes differ between the two procedures. The comparison below outlines the key differences patients typically ask about.

FactorTotal Knee ReplacementPartial (Unicompartmental) Knee Replacement
Portion of knee replacedAll compartments of the jointOnly the damaged compartment (usually medial)
Best candidatesArthritis affecting multiple areas of the kneeArthritis limited to a single compartment, with healthy ligaments
Incision sizeLargerSmaller
Typical recoveryLonger, more extensive rehabilitationFaster, with quicker return to daily activities
Feel of the knee afterwardArtificial joint replicates natural movementOften described as feeling more natural
Future surgery riskLower likelihood of needing revision to a different procedureMay require conversion to total knee replacement later if arthritis progresses

According to Cleveland Clinic, total knee replacements remain more common overall, in part because many patients have arthritis affecting more than one compartment of the knee, which rules out the partial approach.   

How Recovery Between the Two Procedures Differs?

Because a partial knee replacement preserves more of the knee's original ligaments and bone, patients generally experience less post-surgical pain, lower blood loss, and a faster path back to walking and daily activities. Total knee replacement, while more extensive, offers a comprehensive solution for patients whose arthritis has spread throughout the joint, and it carries a strong long-term track record for durability and pain relief.  

Both procedures at Cedar Valley Orthopedics benefit from ARVIS® augmented reality surgical navigation, which provides real-time, precise guidance during surgery to support optimal implant placement, regardless of which procedure is the right fit.            

How a Surgeon Determines Which Approach Fits a Patient's Condition?

Choosing between total and partial knee replacement isn't a decision patients make on their own. An orthopedic surgeon evaluates the extent and location of joint damage through a physical exam and imaging, and considers factors such as ligament health and activity level to recommend the procedure most likely to provide lasting relief.        

Questions to Ask Your Surgeon About Your Specific Case

Patients considering knee replacement often find it helpful to ask their surgeon:

  • Is my arthritis limited to one part of the knee, or does it affect multiple areas?      
  • Am I a candidate for a partial knee replacement, or is total knee replacement the better option for me?          
  • What does recovery typically look like for the recommended procedure?         
  • How is surgical navigation used during my specific procedure?         

Cedar Valley Orthopedics: Your Health Comes First

Whether your arthritis calls for a total or partial knee replacement, the right choice comes down to your specific diagnosis and goals. Cedar Valley Orthopedics' knee specialists can walk you through both options and recommend the approach best suited to your knee.

To find out whether a total or partial knee replacement is right for you, request an appointment with Cedar Valley Orthopedics today.

Appointments

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between total and partial knee replacement?

Total knee replacement resurfaces the entire knee joint and is recommended when arthritis affects multiple areas of the knee. Partial (unicompartmental) knee replacement resurfaces only the damaged section of the knee and is an option when arthritis is limited to a single compartment.

Is partial knee replacement a good option for everyone?

No. Partial knee replacement is only appropriate for patients whose arthritis is confined to one compartment of the knee and whose ligaments are otherwise healthy. Patients with more widespread arthritis are typically better candidates for total knee replacement.

Which recovers faster, total or partial knee replacement?

Partial knee replacement generally involves a smaller incision, less blood loss, and a faster return to daily activities compared with total knee replacement, which involves a more extensive procedure and a longer rehabilitation period.

How do I find a knee replacement specialist near me in Cedar Falls, IA?

Cedar Valley Orthopedics offers both total and partial knee replacement, along with advanced surgical navigation technology, for patients throughout Cedar Falls and the surrounding Cedar Valley. You can request an appointment online to schedule an evaluation.